How precious are Your thoughts to me, O LORD ... how vast is the sum of them!

Tuesday, April 5, 2016

Nancy, Old and New

Nancy Drew is back:
I was excited to recently acquire a 1941 copy of a Nancy Drew mystery, Mystery at the Moss-Covered Mansion. For some time now (especially after reading Girl Sleuth) I’ve been immensely curious about the differences between the original Nancy Drews and the revised editions done starting in the 1960s. Why were they rewritten? What changed? Which would I like better? So I did some sleuthing of my own by reading the two editions of Moss-Covered Mansion back to back. 


I read the 1941 original first. I enjoyed it for the most part (its unconscious details of daily life back then, such as how cars and telephones worked, were helpful for my own story!). It involved an isolated mansion in the woods with shady goings-on, a missing heiress, and a hostile troublemaker. It had twists and turns and red herrings, and I was able to guess a couple of the solutions at the same pace as Nancy Drew, which is always fun. Nancy was clever and delightful. But the mystery plot didn’t seem very tight; Ned Nickerson, Nancy’s boyfriend, made a rather pointless, one-time token appearance; George and Bess, her friends, were paper dolls and completely interchangeable; and the sensibilities toward heritages other than white American were definitely pre-Civil Rights.

So I must admit I liked the 1971 revised edition more. The mystery was completely different – it hardly involved any of the same characters, and the only thing the two books really had in common was the mysterious moss-covered mansion inhabited by wild animals, which concealed two totally different things. (It was interesting to note a couple of “nods” to the original in the 1971, such as a fire, an airplane crash landing, and an impersonator.) It wasn’t the mysteries, though, that made up my mind, because both were good; it was more the characters, structure, and writing.

The newer Nancy Drew seemed more modest and approachable somehow – she’s the girl detective I grew up loving. She didn’t leave Bess and George so far in the dust; they really helped her, and each was a more defined character – bold, Judo-flipping George (I love George almost as much as Nancy) and timid, girly Bess. Having interesting sidekicks made Nancy herself more interesting because of their contrasting personalities. Ned Nickerson was a partner who served a definite purpose in solving the mystery. The story was shorter and more streamlined, and all the action seemed more to the point. No ethnicities were demeaned. I’m a lover of detailed, educational settings in novels, and this one was set in a real place – Merritt Island, Florida, which contains the Kennedy Space Center.

So there’s my honest opinion. In conclusion, this Nancy Drew nerd wants to say: The two are very different books and they each have their own charms – they’re time capsules of two different eras, after all! I’m very glad I read both. And I’m just comparing two editions of one mystery – every other pair will have to be considered in its own right. (Whether I’ll be able to do that myself remains to be seen!)

Have you read the two versions of Nancy Drew? Which do you like better?


  1. As a huge Nancy Drew fan, I really enjoyed reading this! I don't think I've read any of the original mysteries... I didn't realize they were so different.

    1. I didn't realize it, either! I thought they were simply shortened a little and then updated in their language and sensibilities. It's possible that others weren't changed quite as much. I noticed Applewood Press put out renditions of the old versions, so the old Nancy Drews are still available. :)
      I'm glad to encounter another Nancy Drew fan! Thank you for commenting. :)

  2. I had no idea that the "Moss-Covered Mansion" took place on Merritt Island. I lived there for several years--such a cool fact! I'm going to have to re-read it!

    I love the Nancy Drew mysteries from the 1970's. They are much more interesting and seem more well rounded. Though I do agree both versions are distinctly written in relation to the types of novels enjoyed during those eras, I found Nancy and her friends more clever and there is more adventure. :-)

    thanks for sharing!

    1. Wow, you used to live on Merritt Island? That's so cool! Let me know if you reread it and if it sounds like what you know. :)

      I agree with everything you say about the 1970s Nancy Drew mysteries! I'm glad I took the time to collect all 56 of those.

      Thank you for your comment! I love getting opinions on these types of questions. :)